Oceanside Jewish Center
Weekly Parsha

By Jonathan Wolf



















Parshat Re'eh


Moses informs the Children of Israel that they can choose to follow all of the commandments of G-d, and receive a blessing, or reject them and be cursed. A ceremony would be held on the mountains of Gerizim and Eival, immediately after entering the land of Canaan, during which the consequences of the blessings and the curses would be announced.


Moses now reviews the religious (chukim) and civil (mishpotim) laws that the people are to follow in the new land. First is the principle of centralized worship. This was directed against the practice of idolatry prevalent in Canaan at that time. All sacrifices were to be brought only to places designated by G-d. Portions permitted to the people must be eaten there. Consumption of meat for ordinary reasons could be eaten anywhere, provided that none of its blood was consumed.


The people were warned not to imitate the practices of the inhabitants of Canaan. There were to be no self-inflicted wounds in the body or head as a sign of mourning. Tatoos were likewise prohibited. As a holy people, the Children of Israel were forbidden to eat anything abominable such as a creeping thing, a vulture, shell-fish, as well as the other restrictions in the general laws of kashrus.


A second tenth of one’s annual produce (ma’aser sheni) of the soil, including grain, oil, and wine, were to be brought by every Jewish male to the sanctuary, and dedicate it to G-d. It must also be consumed there as well. If the material could not be easily transported, it could be redeemed for money, which then became holy. The money must then be spent, in the vicinity of the Sanctuary (later in Jerusalem), for the purchase of similar goods, which would then be consumed. At the end of every third, and sixth year of the seven year Shemittah cycle, this tenth was to be given to the poor as a


ma’aser oni.


At the end of the Shemittah year, during which the land was to remain fallow, a creditor had to release his fellow Jews from any loans, which may be due. This should not discourage people from giving money to the poor, as acts of kindness would be repaid by G-d. Also, Hebrew slaves were to be freed at the beginning of the seventh year and assisted with the means to sustain themselves. If the slave chose to remain in his master’s service, his ear was to be pierced as a sign that he elected to remain in service.


The parsha ends with Moses reviewing the laws of Pesach, Sukkos, and Shavuos.
Every male was to make a pilgrimage to the Sanctuary, three times a year (shalosh regalim) bringing a sacrifice with them on these festivals.


The parsha’s opening words have a profound lesson for us: “Behold (R’eih), I have placed before you this day (ha’yom) a blessing and a curse…” The word “ha’yom” also means “today”. The sages interpret this to mean that this choice is given to us, even in our times. Everyday, when we recite the Shema, we affirm the yoke of the covenant and the Torah. Each of us makes choices based on their own life experiences. It would seem that with the prospect of a blessing and a curse, the way to choose should be obvious. It is not that simple. Sometimes, what we consider to be a blessing, is actually a curse (and vice versa). It is not in our power to foresee the future. When our bodies feel pain, we may consider this a curse, but it is actually a warning sign telling us that something is wrong. Some of the most dangerous diseases occur without warning, and without pain or symptoms (until it’s too late).


The sages discuss this concept in a parable. A man sits at the crossroads between two roads. One of them starts smooth and open, but ends in thorns and narrow windings. The other road, starts off rough and difficult, but ends up smooth and open. This, the sages say, applies to our verse in the parsha. While evil may seem to succeed today, in this world, their punishment will occur later, in the World to come. On the other hand, the suffering endured by some in this world, will be rewarded richly in the next. This may seem to be an attempt to explain why bad things happen to good people. It is a rational way to try and explain the unexplainable. We don’t know why some people die young. We don’t know why some cheaters prosper and live richly until old age. Without all of the facts, life is journey filled with mysteries. The sages tried to make sense of it all within the framework of the Torah.


One of the things we have control over is how we personally deal with adversity. How we deal with death is sometimes just as important as how we deal with life. We also have control over how we act toward one another. There are many mitzvos in this parsha dealing with kindness toward the widow, the orphan, the blind, and the poor. The Torah says:

“If there be among you a needy man, one of your brethren within any of your gates, in your land which the Lord your G-d gives you, you shall not harden your heart nor shut your hand from your needy brother. You shall surely open your hand unto him and shall surely lend him sufficient for his need which he lacks.”


The Talmud, in tractate Taanis 21a, tells the story about Nochum Ish Gam Zu. The phrase “gam zu l’tova” means, “this too, is for the best”. Nochum was totally blind. He was missing both of his hands and feet and his body was completely covered with sores and boils. His house was in danger of collapsing and his disciples wanted to remove his bed first and then remove the rest of his furniture. Nochum told them, “First remove the furniture and then remove my bed, because it is assured that as long as I am in this house, it will not collapse.” The students removed the furniture and then removed Nochum on his bed. The house then collapsed.


His disciples asked him, “Our master, since you are such a righteous man, why is it your lot to suffer so much?” Nochum relpied, “My sons, I brought this on upon myself. I was once traveling on the road going to my father-in-law’s house with three donkeys; one laden with food, one laden with drink, and the other laden with delicacies. A poor man approached me and asked for food. I told him to wait until I unloaded the donkey. Before I had a chance to finish, the man died. I fell near his face and cried, ‘My eyes that did not have compassion on your eyes, should go blind. My hands and feet that did not have compassion on your hands and feet, should be severed.’ I wasn’t satisfied until I said that my body should also be covered with sores and boils.” “Woe to us that we see you in this condition”, said the disciples. Nochum replied, “Woe to me if you would not have seen me in this condition.”


The story may be far fetched, but it serves as an important lesson. Unlike Job, who wondered why, as a righteous person, he was destined to suffer, Nochum understands that his suffering is a direct consequence of his inaction to help someone in need. Recall the story of Beauty and The Beast, in which the Prince is punished for turning away an ugly beggar woman who turned out to be an enchantress. She casts a spell on him, turning him into the hideous beast until he can find true love.

Unfortunately, the consequences of our choices today are not always apparent. Clearly, if you drink and then drive, there will be a consequence as we tragically hear about all the time. If you make a wrong choice in an investment, it may take years to find out if you reap a reward. Smoking is a habit that may take decades to rear its deadly effects. The main point is that there are consequences for our actions. How we conduct ourselves in private and public is a part of Torah Law.


The word for charity is “tzedakah”. This word also means “righteous”. It should not be surprising that aiding the poor is an act of righteousness. However, we must be careful not to embarrass someone. There is an old saying, “Give a man a fish and you feed him once. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime.” We can never be sure what the impact will be on our actions. The study of Torah is not an isolated act. It must be accompanied by action or it will not endure. This is what Judaism demands from us. In a Talmudic debate between the sages, the question was raised. Which is more important, study or action. The gemara answers that study is more important, since it leads to action. Action and good deeds must never be left out the equation. The trick is to find the balance.


The Torah will teach us what we must do and how must act. Then, we must go out into the real world. There is a story about a young prodigy of learning who became world famous because of his erudite insights into the Torah. A Rabbi made a journey to witness this phenomenon for himself. He traveled to the boy’s yeshiva and asked his teacher if it was true that the boy knows so much. “To tell you the truth”, said the teacher, “the boy studies so much, I don’t know where he finds the time to know anything!” In the same way, we can learn a lot by observing the actions of righteous people. They are themselves, the embodiment of a living Sefer Torah. This is why the sages tell us to rise in the presence of the aged.


The story is told about a poor man who once came to the home of Rabbi Boruch ber Leibowitz to ask for a handout. Rabbi Leibowitz, who was very poor himself, did not have any money to give. As the poor man left his home, Rabbi Leibowitz accompanied him and they walked together for quite a distance. When the rabbi’s disciples came, they saw their teacher walking with the man. It was quite obvious that the man was enjoying the attention given to him by such a great sage. Afterward, Rabbi Leibowitz explained his behavior to his students. “A beggar humiliates himself because of the charity he asks for. If I am unable to give him any money, the least I can do is give him back his honor”.


One of the heads of the House of Rothschild was once asked how much his great fortune totaled. He reached into a drawer and took out a book that bore his careful entries about all of the charitable contributions. Patiently, he added up all the figures and presented them as the sum total of his wealth. Thinking that he took the wrong book, his secretary then fetched the ledger with all of his business assets. “No”, Mr. Rothschild replied gently, “I have the right book. I know I own large amounts of properties, mines, and investments. But the mines may flood, the market may go down, and my properties may lose value. No, what I am worth can be demonstrated by what it shows in this book of charitable contributions. These are really mine, this is what I am worth, and nobody can take that away from me.”


We have a chance “today” to follow what the Torah says so let’s make the most of it. Beware the haughtiness success brings because you might be on the other end one day!